A cross-platform comparison of Raleigh-area roofing contractors using Google, Yelp, BBB, Angi, Facebook, and Thumbtack reputation signals.
Triangle Roofing Report reviewed the Raleigh-area roofers with the largest Google review profiles, then compared their public reputation signals across additional platforms. The final order weighs rating strength, review volume, platform coverage, consistency, Facebook recommendation rate, and BBB standing.
Each contractor name in the table links to a dedicated cross-platform review profile with platform-by-platform ratings, review counts, service areas, and methodology notes.
| Rank | Contractor | Score | Yelp | BBB | Angi | Thumbtack | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Barkley-Jensen Roofing and RestorationFull contractor profile | 94 | 5.0 avg380 reviews | 5.0 avg3 reviews | 5.0 avg55 reviews - A+ | 5.0 avg62 reviews | 100% recommend17 recommendations | 5.0 avg106 reviews |
| 2 | A&M Premiere Roofing & ConstructionFull contractor profile | 92 | 4.9 avg826 reviews | 4.1 avg10 reviews | 4.92 avg169 reviews - A+ | 5.0 avg59 reviews | 100% recommend72 recommendations | Rating: N/AN/A |
| 3 | Artisan Quality RoofingFull contractor profile | 91 | 5.0 avg409 reviews | 4.7 avg46 reviews | 5.0 avg1 review - A+ | 5.0 avg119 reviews | 100% recommend37 recommendations | Rating: N/AN/A |
| 4 | On Tops RoofingFull contractor profile | 89 | 5.0 avg591 reviews | 4.1 avg17 reviews | 4.84 avg19 reviews - A+ | Rating: N/AN/A | 100% recommend25 recommendations | 5.0 avg37 reviews |
| 5 | Legacy Construction and RoofingFull contractor profile | 88 | 4.9 avg414 reviews | 4.7 avg23 reviews | 5.0 avg36 reviews - A+ | 4.7 avg23 reviews | 100% recommend6 recommendations | Rating: N/AN/A |
| 6 | Storm Guard Roofing and Construction Durham Chapel HillFull contractor profile | 86 | 5.0 avg353 reviews | 4.8 avg18 reviews | 5.0 avg10 reviews - A+ | Rating: N/AN/A | 100% recommend38 recommendations | Rating: N/AN/A |
| 7 | Roofwerks, Inc.Full contractor profile | 82 | 4.8 avg591 reviews | 4.1 avg54 reviews | 4.0 avg4 reviews - A+ | 4.6 avg28 reviews | 96% recommend41 recommendations | Rating: N/AN/A |
| 8 | Baker Home ExteriorsFull contractor profile | 78 | 4.8 avg747 reviews | 3.9 avg50 reviews | Rating: N/A0 reviews - A+ | Rating: N/AN/A | 90% recommend79 recommendations | Rating: N/AN/A |
| 9 | Feazel RoofingFull contractor profile | 76 | 4.7 avg606 reviews | 3.4 avg20 reviews | 4.77 avg125 reviews - A+ | Rating: N/AN/A | 72% recommend96 recommendations | 4.6 avg10 reviews |
| 10 | The Shingle MasterFull contractor profile | 74 | 4.9 avg552 reviews | 3.0 avg2 reviews | 3.86 avg7 reviews - A+ | 4.7 avg38 reviews | 94% recommend11 recommendations | 5.0 avg12 reviews |
Table cells show the average rating or recommendation percentage on the first line, and review or recommendation volume on the second line. N/A means a usable listing or rating was not found during verification and is not treated as a zero-star rating.
Barkley-Jensen ranks first because it has the strongest cross-platform consistency in the group: 5.0 ratings on Google, Yelp, BBB customer reviews, Angi, and Thumbtack, plus a 100% Facebook recommendation rate.
The score weighs public reputation signals available June 25-26, 2026: rating strength across star-rated platforms, visible review and recommendation volume, platform coverage, rating consistency, Facebook recommendation percentage, and BBB standing. Missing listings are marked N/A and are not counted as zero.
Ratings and review counts change over time. "Best" refers to this published reputation-data methodology, not a guarantee of project outcome. Inclusion is not an endorsement, and homeowners should independently verify licensing, insurance, references, warranties, and estimates.